Tag Archives: Eighth Circuit

Party Waived Argument By Not Citing the Correct Circuit Authority in the District Court, Holds Split Eighth Circuit Panel

In Meinen v. Bi-State Development Agency, No. 231242 (8th Cir. May 16, 2024), a 2-1 Eighth Circuit panel held that the party’s failure to cite a favorable Eighth Circuit case in the district court thereby forfeited an legal argument based on that case. The dissent notes that this holding creates a split in the circuits.Continue reading “Party Waived Argument By Not Citing the Correct Circuit Authority in the District Court, Holds Split Eighth Circuit Panel”

County Cop’s Hot Pursuit of Suspect Across State Line Was “Purposeful Availment” for Personal Jurisdiction Purposes, Holds Eighth Circuit

In a terse five-page opinion, an Eighth Circuit panel in Wade v. Pottawattamie Cnty. No. 23-1059 (8th Cir. May 7, 2024), reverses a decision that dismissed, on personal jurisdiction grounds, a lawsuit against an Iowa county in a personal injury case involving a deputy crossing state lines. “The unfortunate chain of events began when aContinue reading “County Cop’s Hot Pursuit of Suspect Across State Line Was “Purposeful Availment” for Personal Jurisdiction Purposes, Holds Eighth Circuit”

Rule 11 Did Not Apply to Party Already Dismissed from the Action, Holds Eighth Circuit

In Martin Leigh PC  v.  Leyh, No. 22-1975 (8th Cir. Apr. 3, 2024), an Eighth Circuit panel holds that when a party had already been dismissed from an action for two months, it is too late to invoke Rule 11 by operation of the Fed. R. Civ. P. 11(c)(2) 21-day safe-harbor provision. “On October 5,Continue reading “Rule 11 Did Not Apply to Party Already Dismissed from the Action, Holds Eighth Circuit”

“Law of the Case” Does Not Apply to Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Ruling by Motion Panel, Holds Split Eighth Circuit Panel

In Nordgren  v.  Hennepin Cnty., No. 22-1902 (8th Cir. Mar. 21, 2024), a 2-1 Eighth Circuit panel holds that a merits panel may reconsider the timeliness of an appeal even after a motion panel has already denied a motion to dismiss on the same ground, notwithstanding the “law of the case” doctrine. In a §Continue reading ““Law of the Case” Does Not Apply to Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Ruling by Motion Panel, Holds Split Eighth Circuit Panel”

Lawsuit to Unseal Court Records Fails Because No Defendant Was Named, Holds Eighth Circuit

In Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press v. United States of America, No. 22-3326 (8th Cir. Mar. 1, 2024), the Eighth Circuit affirms dismissal of an action for lack of jurisdiction on the ground that there was no “adversity” between the parties, owing to the supposed failure of plaintiff to name a defendant inContinue reading “Lawsuit to Unseal Court Records Fails Because No Defendant Was Named, Holds Eighth Circuit”

Eighth Circuit Holds That Hospital’s Creation of Online Patient Portal Did Not Bring State-Law Privacy Claim Within the Federal Officer Removal Statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1)

In Doe v. BJC Health Sys., No. 23-1107 (8th Cir. Dec. 28, 2023), the Eighth Circuit – rejecting the persuasive authority of two district court opinions – holds that a hospital’s adoption of a online patient portal under the 2009 Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act did not bring a state-lawContinue reading “Eighth Circuit Holds That Hospital’s Creation of Online Patient Portal Did Not Bring State-Law Privacy Claim Within the Federal Officer Removal Statute, 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a)(1)”

After the Parties Settle All Claims, An Appeal From the Final Judgment Is Moot, Holds Eighth Circuit

In Folta v. Norfork Brewing Co., No. 22-3518 (8th Cir. Dec. 22, 2023), the Eighth Circuit dismisses an appeal from a case where all the claims settled, despite the defendant’s argument that it reserved the right to appeal in the settlement. “Norfork operates a small brewery in Arkansas. Folta was employed there from approximately MayContinue reading “After the Parties Settle All Claims, An Appeal From the Final Judgment Is Moot, Holds Eighth Circuit”

Federal Equitable Power Did Not Extend to Returning Seized Cell Phone to “My Pillow” CEO, Holds Eighth Circuit

In Lindell v. United States, No. 22-3510 (8th Cir. Sept. 23, 2023), the Eighth Circuit affirms a district court’s denial of a preliminary injunction to MyPillow, Inc. and its Chief Executive Officer Michael Lindell to return “Lindell’s cell phone that was seized by federal agents on September 13, 2022.” The panel splits, though, on whetherContinue reading “Federal Equitable Power Did Not Extend to Returning Seized Cell Phone to “My Pillow” CEO, Holds Eighth Circuit”

Eighth Circuit Holds That Stipulations About Citizenship Are Not Binding When Evaluating Diversity Jurisdiction, Signaling a Possible Split with Other Circuits

In Great River Entertainment, LLC  v.  Zurich American Ins. Co., No. 21-3815 (8th Cir. Sept. 11, 2023), the Eighth Circuit reverses and remands a final judgment dismissing this insurance coverage lawsuit, holding that—despite an admission by the plaintiff in the district court that the parties were diverse—the plaintiff could contradict that stipulation on appeal withContinue reading “Eighth Circuit Holds That Stipulations About Citizenship Are Not Binding When Evaluating Diversity Jurisdiction, Signaling a Possible Split with Other Circuits”

Eighth Circuit Holds That There Is No Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Over Removed Case Once Plaintiff Amends Their Complaint to Strip Out All Federal-Law Allegations, Noting Split with Second and Fifth Circuits

In Wullschleger  v.  Royal Canin U.S.A., Inc., No. 22-1796 (8th Cir. July 31, 2023), on its second trip to the Eighth Circuit, the court holds that a class-action plaintiff successfully outfoxed the defendants by promptly amending their removed complaint to strike out all federal-law allegations, thus depriving the district court of subject-matter jurisdiction. This isContinue reading “Eighth Circuit Holds That There Is No Subject-Matter Jurisdiction Over Removed Case Once Plaintiff Amends Their Complaint to Strip Out All Federal-Law Allegations, Noting Split with Second and Fifth Circuits”