Third Circuit Holds That an Attorney Does Not Establish Specific Personal Jurisdiction Over a Company Simply by Purchasing One of Its Products on Amazon and Having It Shipped to Their Office, Contributing to a Circuit Split

In Promier Products Inc v. Gearoz, No. 25-2407 (3d Cir. Nov. 20, 2026), the Third Circuit clarifies that it is not enough to establish specific personal jurisdiction in a Lanham Act case for a lawyer to buy a product over the internet from their home state. The panel nevertheless remands the case to determine whether the defendantsmay have waived the argument.

“Promier Products sells flashlights online through Amazon. A flashlight’s big selling point is its brightness. Promier worried that other Amazon sellers were lying about how bright their competing flashlights are. So it hired a Pittsburgh law firm to investigate. To measure the flashlights’ brightness, the law firm bought some on Amazon and had them shipped to its Pittsburgh office.” According to the pleadings in this case, most of the plaintiff’s competitors misrepresented their products. It sued 153 companies under Pennsylvania common law and the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. §1125(a).

The district court ordered plaintiff to show cause why the claims, all of them against Chinese companies not located in Pennsylvania, should not be dismissed on personal jurisdiction grounds. After some procedural wrangling, the court held that “Promier’s lawyers could not use their own test buys to manufacture [specific personal] jurisdiction.”

The Third Circuit affirms in part and remands in part. The case was on appeal from the district court’s denial of a preliminary injunction to bar defendants from making false claims about their flashlights. At that procedural stage, when the defense is properly raised, a district court must find “a reasonable likelihood that the court has personal jurisdiction.” The defendant companies had no physical presence in Pennsylvania and there was no evidence of sales in Pennsylvania other than to the Pittsburgh lawyers.

The panel notes that for purposes of specific personal jurisdiction, “[l]isting a product on Amazon’s website is not a contact with Pennsylvania.” While the shipment of a product into a state may be a contact with the forum, to furnish grounds for jurisdiction “it would have to be coupled with a claim that is closely related to that shipment.”

“Promier’s false-advertising claims thus arise out of defendants’ sales to deceived consumers—not Promier’s lawyers. After all, the law firm ‘obviously was not confused’ about the goods’ qualities . . . . And though the claims also arise out of defendants’ listings on Amazon, those listings are not contacts with Pennsylvania specifically . . . . So Promier has not shown that its claims were directly caused by any contacts that defendants made with Pennsylvania.”

“To show [specific] personal jurisdiction at trial, Promier will need to prove at least one sale to a deceived consumer in Pennsylvania by a preponderance of the evidence (though we do not decide whether only one sale would be enough). So for a preliminary injunction, Promier must show a reasonable likelihood that it will eventually be able to prove that. This requires more than just showing that the defendants offered goods for nationwide sale through Amazon.”

“The question is: Based on the evidence before us, how likely is it that evidence of actual sales will follow? And here, the sales to Promier’s lawyers add nothing beyond what a screenshot of an Amazon profile would reveal— that defendants are willing and able to ship to all fifty states. So the District Court did not err in finding that Promier’s evidence fell short.”

The panel notes that five other circuits addressing this same question arrived at different outcomes on similar facts.

Finally, the panel remands some of the defendants to address an argument that they waived the defense of personal jurisdiction by answering instead of moving to dismiss under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(2) and 12(h)(1).

Leave a Reply