In Moyer v. GEICO, No. 23-4015 (6th Cir. Aug. 26, 2024), the Sixth Circuit reverses dismissal of an ERISA case when the plaintiff raised “legitimate questions” about the completeness of the plan documents attached to defendant’s Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss. “Cases often depend on the contents of legal instruments, such asContinue reading “Sixth Circuit Holds That “Legitimate Questions” About Content of Legal Instruments Attached to Defendant’s Motion Precludes Dismissal Under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6)”
Category Archives: Uncategorized
Ninth Circuit Resolves Intracircuit Conflict on Law-of-the-Case, Tightening Standard for Successor Judge Reconsideration of Prior Decisions
In Zeyen v. Bonneville Joint Dist., No. 23-35438 (9th Cir. Aug. 23, 2024), the Ninth Circuit holds that when an open case is reassigned to a new district court judge, the successor may only reverse a predecessor’s decision when it is both “clearly erroneous and . . . its enforcement would work a manifest injustice.”Continue reading “Ninth Circuit Resolves Intracircuit Conflict on Law-of-the-Case, Tightening Standard for Successor Judge Reconsideration of Prior Decisions”
Eleventh Circuit Affirms Judgment as a Matter of Law Tossing a $300 Million Verdict, Owing to Admission of Hearsay Valuation Evidence, Yet Remands for a New Trial on Damages
In Taxinet Corp. v. Leon, No. 22-12335 (11th Cir. Aug. 19, 2024), the Eleventh Circuit affirms judgment as a matter of law that wiped out a $300 million jury verdict on a state law unjust-enrichment claim, after the district court held that it erred in admitting hearsay valuation evidence. Yet the panel exercises discretion toContinue reading “Eleventh Circuit Affirms Judgment as a Matter of Law Tossing a $300 Million Verdict, Owing to Admission of Hearsay Valuation Evidence, Yet Remands for a New Trial on Damages”
Second Circuit Reverses District Court’s Post-Trial Tripling of Jury Award of Damages, Finding No Fundamental Error in Jury Verdict
In Salamone v. Douglas Marine Corp., No. 21-1331 (2d Cir. Aug. 8, 2024), the Second Circuit affirms a jury verdict in a state-law contract case, but reverses the district court’s post-verdict tripling of the damages, holding that the plaintiff forfeited a challenge to the jury’s calculation and there was no fundamental error warranting judicial interventionContinue reading “Second Circuit Reverses District Court’s Post-Trial Tripling of Jury Award of Damages, Finding No Fundamental Error in Jury Verdict”
Alleged Shoving Match Between Counsel at a Deposition Leads to Sanctions and an Appeal to the Seventh Circuit
In Vega v. Chicago Bd. of Ed., No. 23-1183 (7th Cir. July 29, 2024), the Seventh Circuit affirms in part and reverses in part sanctions awarded by the district court under 28 U.S.C. § 1927 and the court’s inherent authority after an acrimonious deposition that allegedly led to a physical confrontation. “On July 13, 2017,Continue reading “Alleged Shoving Match Between Counsel at a Deposition Leads to Sanctions and an Appeal to the Seventh Circuit”
Third Circuit Holds That Private Process Server Fees Are Not a Taxable Cost Under Section 1920(1), Adding to a Circuit Split
In Knowles v. Temple Univ., No. 22-2978 (7th Cir. July 26, 2024), the Third Circuit contributes to the circuit split about whether private process-server fees are taxable costs as “[f]ees of the clerk and marshal” under 28 U.S.C. § 1920(1) and Fed. R. Civ. P. 54(d). The panel holds that they are not taxable, thusContinue reading “Third Circuit Holds That Private Process Server Fees Are Not a Taxable Cost Under Section 1920(1), Adding to a Circuit Split”
Fourth Circuit Holds That “General Merger Rule” of Newly Amended Fed. R. App. P. 3(c)(4) Means That Notice of Appeal of Summary Judgment Confers Appellate Jurisdiction Over an Interlocutory Order Denying Appointment of Counsel
In Jenkins v. Woodard, No. 22-6197 (4th Cir. July 22, 2024), the Fourth Circuit confronts an issue arising under 2021 amendment to Fed. R. App. P. 3: how to apply the new “general merger rule” to a federal notice of appeal that names just the summary judgment order. The amendment of Rule 3 was meantContinue reading “Fourth Circuit Holds That “General Merger Rule” of Newly Amended Fed. R. App. P. 3(c)(4) Means That Notice of Appeal of Summary Judgment Confers Appellate Jurisdiction Over an Interlocutory Order Denying Appointment of Counsel”
Divided Second Circuit Panel Invokes 1872 Supreme Court Decision to Toss a Default Judgment, Owing to Inconsistency in the Jury Verdict
In Henry v. Oluwole, No. 21-2468 (2d Cir. July 15, 2024), a 2-1 panel of the Second Circuit holds not only that the district court erred in refusing to reopen a default judgment before and after a jury trial, but that judgment had to be entered for the party in default due to a fatalContinue reading “Divided Second Circuit Panel Invokes 1872 Supreme Court Decision to Toss a Default Judgment, Owing to Inconsistency in the Jury Verdict”
Eleventh Circuit Judge, in Concurring Opinion, Challenges Expansion of Younger Abstention as Chilling First Amendment Rights
In a case involving Stacey Abrams’ New Georgia Project, the Eleventh Circuit holds in New Georgia Project, Inc., et al v. Attorney General, State of Georgia, No. 22-14302 (11th Cir. July 8, 2024), that federal litigation of a challenge to Georgia’s campaign laws must await the conclusion of a state administrative enforcement action against theContinue reading “Eleventh Circuit Judge, in Concurring Opinion, Challenges Expansion of Younger Abstention as Chilling First Amendment Rights”
Fugitive-Disentitlement Doctrine Dooms Criminal Appeal of Defendant Who Fled the Country, Holds Ninth Circuit
Another case involving one of my favorite federal common law rules: in United States v. Terabelian, No. 21-50291 (9th Cir. June 27, 2024), the Ninth Circuit dismisses the direct appeal of a criminal conviction on the ground that the defendant removed her location-monitoring device and fled to country to Montenegro before sentencing, citing the fugitive-disentitlementContinue reading “Fugitive-Disentitlement Doctrine Dooms Criminal Appeal of Defendant Who Fled the Country, Holds Ninth Circuit”
Paul Mollica's Federal Courts Blog 