In Continental Indem. Co. v. BII, Inc., N. 23-1648 (7th Cir. June 12, 2024), the Seventh Circuit affirms dismissal of an action filed under Fed. R. Civ. P. 69 by an insurer against an alleged garnishee, holding that it fell outside the court’s ancillary enforcement jurisdiction. The panel, though, reserves for future consideration whether theContinue reading “Seventh Circuit Questions Standard of Review for Orders Declining to Exercise Ancillary Enforcement Jurisdiction”
Category Archives: Uncategorized
D.C. Circuit Vacates “Sledgehammer” Pre-Filing Injunction Against Frequent Filer That Applied to Every Court in the Nation
In Klayman v. Porter, No. 22-7123 (D.C. Cir. June 11, 2024), the D.C. Circuit strikes down the sanction of “restricting [plaintiff]’s ability to file any related actions or claims for relief in any forum, state or federal,” citing prudential and constitutional limits to federal equitable power. “In recent years, the District of Columbia Bar’s OfficeContinue reading “D.C. Circuit Vacates “Sledgehammer” Pre-Filing Injunction Against Frequent Filer That Applied to Every Court in the Nation”
Seventh Circuit Takes Time Out to Berate Bernhard Modern Font
In Asimah v. CBL & Assoc. Mgt, Inc., No. 23-2495 (7th Cir. June 3, 2024), a decision otherwise dismissing a case based on a defect in the notice of appeal, the Seventh Circuit devotes a couple of pages to typography. “We are publishing this opinion . . . to urge all lawyers to read andContinue reading “Seventh Circuit Takes Time Out to Berate Bernhard Modern Font”
Sixth Circuit Finds Fed. R. Civ. P. 54(b) Certification Improper Where Wrongful Death Claim on Appeal Arose from Same Facts as Negligence and Other Causes of Action
In Sherrod v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., No. 21-3428 (6th Cir. May 29, 2024), the Sixth Circuit dismisses an appeal of a wrongful death claim against Wal-Mart—presenting truly bizarre facts—where the panel finds that it should not have been certified for appeal under Rule 54(b) because it was too interrelated with unadjudicated causes of action forContinue reading “Sixth Circuit Finds Fed. R. Civ. P. 54(b) Certification Improper Where Wrongful Death Claim on Appeal Arose from Same Facts as Negligence and Other Causes of Action”
Ninth Circuit Holds That It Had Jurisdiction Under Collateral-Order Doctrine to Review Sanction Against U.S. Attorney
In United States v. Cloud, No. 22-30044 (9th Cir. May 21, 2024), the Ninth Circuit holds that even before entry of a conviction against the criminal defendant, the United States could appeal a district court order, under the collateral-order, directing the Government to pay monetary sanctions for an alleged Brady violation. Mid-trial during a homicideContinue reading “Ninth Circuit Holds That It Had Jurisdiction Under Collateral-Order Doctrine to Review Sanction Against U.S. Attorney”
Party Waived Argument By Not Citing the Correct Circuit Authority in the District Court, Holds Split Eighth Circuit Panel
In Meinen v. Bi-State Development Agency, No. 231242 (8th Cir. May 16, 2024), a 2-1 Eighth Circuit panel held that the party’s failure to cite a favorable Eighth Circuit case in the district court thereby forfeited an legal argument based on that case. The dissent notes that this holding creates a split in the circuits.Continue reading “Party Waived Argument By Not Citing the Correct Circuit Authority in the District Court, Holds Split Eighth Circuit Panel”
Session Replay Code Embedded in Retail Website Did Not Constitute “Purposeful Availment” of State Where Customer Was Located, Holds First Circuit
In Rosenthal v. Bloomingdales.com, LLC, No. 23-1683 (1st Cir. May 9, 2024), a First Circuit panel holds that the inclusion of a session replay provider (SRP) on a commercial website hosted out of state, which allegedly permitted surveillance of customers, did not create grounds for specific personal jurisdiction against the store in the state whereContinue reading “Session Replay Code Embedded in Retail Website Did Not Constitute “Purposeful Availment” of State Where Customer Was Located, Holds First Circuit”
County Cop’s Hot Pursuit of Suspect Across State Line Was “Purposeful Availment” for Personal Jurisdiction Purposes, Holds Eighth Circuit
In a terse five-page opinion, an Eighth Circuit panel in Wade v. Pottawattamie Cnty. No. 23-1059 (8th Cir. May 7, 2024), reverses a decision that dismissed, on personal jurisdiction grounds, a lawsuit against an Iowa county in a personal injury case involving a deputy crossing state lines. “The unfortunate chain of events began when aContinue reading “County Cop’s Hot Pursuit of Suspect Across State Line Was “Purposeful Availment” for Personal Jurisdiction Purposes, Holds Eighth Circuit”
Defendant’s “Strategic Decision” to Withhold Challenge to Diversity Jurisdiction for Fifteen Months Warrants $62,556 Attorney’s Fee Sanction Under Court’s Inherent Powers
In J.C. Penney Corporation, Inc. v. Oxford Mall, LLC, No. 22-12461 (11th Cir. May 1, 2024), the Eleventh Circuit affirms in full an attorney’s fee sanction, awarded against a defendant that was found to have withheld information for fifteen months that the parties were not diverse for purposes of 28 U.S.C. § 1332 subject-matter jurisdiction.Continue reading “Defendant’s “Strategic Decision” to Withhold Challenge to Diversity Jurisdiction for Fifteen Months Warrants $62,556 Attorney’s Fee Sanction Under Court’s Inherent Powers”
Denial of Anti-SLAPP Motion to Dismiss Not Appealable Under Collateral-Order Doctrine Holds Tenth Circuit, Noting Split in Circuits
In Coomer v. Make Your Life Epic LLC, No. 23-1109 (10th Cir. Apr. 23, 2024), the Tenth Circuit dismissed an attempted appeal of an order denying a “special motion to dismiss” under a state anti-SLAPP statue, holding that it did not fit within the confines of the collateral-order doctrine. Many jurisdictions have anti-SLAPP (Strategic LawsuitContinue reading “Denial of Anti-SLAPP Motion to Dismiss Not Appealable Under Collateral-Order Doctrine Holds Tenth Circuit, Noting Split in Circuits”
Paul Mollica's Federal Courts Blog 